My husband (Muhammad) and I are really stuck on 5 names we have picked out which all are most beautiful and also Holy but still cant decide which one our them would suit our first born and hoping inchallah you can help??

Ali, Ibrahim, Ushaa, Jacob, and Isaac...

If the meaning is good then it is completely up to you what name you choose, it depends on what you like. Personally I like Ibrahim (and the father's name is Muhammad like Prophet Muhammad who had a son by the name of Ibrahim), but another person may like Ali.

See which name your heart likes the most, and inshAllah you can choose that. And in your prayers ask Allah to help you in choosing a name and inshAllah His help will come to you sooner or later.